Menu | Baked Goods By Natalie

no- bake chocolate peanut butter oatmeal cookies

homemade no-bake chocolate peanut butter oatmeal cookies made with creamy peanut butter, rich cocoa, and wholesome oats. soft, chewy, and full of nostalgic flavor.

half a dozen(6)

a dozen (12)

$10

two dozen (24)

$15

three dozen (36)

$20

Peanuts

milk

no- bake chocolate peanut butter oatmeal cookies

Featured

custom sugar cookies

hand-decorated sugar cookies made from a delicious buttery vanilla recipe and topped with royal icing. fresh, customizable, and perfect for any celebration.

half a dozen(6)

$20

a dozen (12)

$40

two dozen (24)

$75

three dozen (36)

$110

milk

Wheat

Eggs

add- ons

individual ribbon/tags (packaging )

$1.00

metallic gold/silver details (per cookie)

$5.00

character/logo designs (per cookie)

$10

Featured

chocolate chip cookies

a classical favorite! these homemade chocolate chip cookies are made with real butter, brown sugar, and plenty of chocolate chips for the perfect soft and chewy texture .

half a dozen(6)

a dozen (12)

$12

two dozen (24)

$22

three dozen (36)

$32

Wheat

milk

Eggs

Soy

toppings/ add-on/ packaging/mix-ins

extra chocolate chips (per dozen)

dark chocolate chips (per dozen)

white chocolate chips (per dozen)

Featured

peanut butter cookies

homemade peanut butter cookies baked for a soft, chewy, and classic flavor.

half a dozen(6)

a dozen (12)

$10

two dozen (24)

$18

three dozen (36)

$26

Wheat

milk

Peanuts

Eggs

add-ins/add-ons

chocolate chips (per dozen)

mini chocolate chips (per dozen)

reese's pieces (per dozen)

Featured

M&M cookies

soft and chewy homemade cookies loaded with M&Ms. fun, sweet, and perfect for any occasion.

individual squares

half a dozen(6)

$18

a dozen (12)

$32

two dozen (24)

$60

three dozen (36)

$96

Wheat

milk

Eggs

Soy

add-ins/ toppings

extra M&Ms (per dozen)

mimi M&Ms (per dozen)

peanut M&Ms (per dozen)

Featured

cookie cake

a thick, soft -baked chocolate cookie decorated with creamy buttercream frosting . perfect for birthday, graduation, parties, and special occasions, this crowd-pleasing dessert combines the best of cookies and cake in one delicious treat.

8-inch

10- inch

12-inch

Wheat

milk

Eggs

Soy

add-ons

chocolate chips

extra chocolate chips

M&M's

cupcakes

Featured

vanilla cupcakes

classic homemade vanilla cupcakes topped with creamy buttercream frosting. light, fluffy, and delicious

half a dozen(6)

$10

a dozen (12)

$18

two dozen (24)

$34

three dozen (36)

$68

Wheat

milk

Eggs

add- ons

extra frosting swirl (per dozen)

sprinkles (per dozen)

fillings (per dozen)

Featured

chocolate cupcakes

moist homemade chocolate cupcakes topped with rich buttercream frosting.

half a dozen(6)

$11

a dozen (12)

$20

two dozen (24)

$38

three dozen (36)

Wheat

milk

Eggs

add- ons

chocolate baked in

chocolate ganache topping

filling

Featured

red velvet

classicred velvet cupcakes topped with rich cream cheese frosting.

half a dozen(6)

$12

a dozen (12)

$22

two dozen (24)

$42

milk

Wheat

Eggs

add-ons

cream cheese extra swirl (per dozen )

heart toppers (per dozen)

$5.00

filling(per dozen)

Featured

funfetti cupcakes

colorful sprinkle-filled cupcakes topped with sweet vanilla frosting.

half a dozen(6)

$11

a dozen (12)

$20

two dozen (24)

$38

Wheat

milk

Eggs

add-ons

extra sprinkles (per dozen)

confetti filing (per dozen)

rainbow frosting swirl (per dozen)

Featured

strawberry cupcakes

fresh strawberry cupcakes topped with sweet butter cream frosting

half a dozen(6)

$12

a dozen (12)

$22

two dozen (24)

$42

milk

Wheat

Eggs

add-ons

strawberry fillings

fresh strawberry topping

chocolate drizzle (per dozen)

tres leches cupcakes

moist vanilla cupcakes soaked in a sweet three- milk mixture and topped with whipped cream. creamy, rich, and melt - in- your-mouth delicious

half a dozen(6)

$14

a dozen (12)

$26

two dozen (24)

$50

Wheat

milk

Eggs

add-ons (per dozen)

extra milk

dulce de leche drizzle

caramel drizzle

cakes

Featured

custom birthday cakes

celebrate any special occasion with a custom birthday cake made from scratch and decorated to match your theme, available in a varietyof flavors, fillings, and frosting options, each cake is designed to make your celebration extra sweet and memorable.

6-inch

$35

8-inch

$50

10- inch

$65

milk

Wheat

Eggs

add- ons

custom theme decorations

$10

name and age topper

butter cream flowers

$10

Chocolate Brownie

Decadent brownie with a fudgy center and a sprinkle of sea salt on top.

$3.50

Gluten free

chocolate cake

rich, moist chocolate cake layered with creamy chocolate buttercream frosting. a classic favorite for birthdays, holidays, and chocolate lovers alike.

6-inch

$35

8-inch

$50

10- inch

$65

add-ons

chocolate ganache

chocolate covered strawberries

$10

choclate drip

Featured

vanilla cake

light, fluffy vanilla cake made from scratch and paired with smooth vanilla buttercream frosting. a timeless dessert thats perfect for any celebration.

6-inch

$35

8-inch

$50

10- inch

$65

Wheat

milk

Eggs

add-ons

vanilla cream fillings

sprinkles

buttercream flowers

$10

Featured

strawberry cake

soft strawberry cake bursting with sweet strawberry flavor and topped with creamy strawberry buttercream frosting. a delicious choice for spring, summer and berry lovers

6-inch

$40

8-inch

$55

10- inch

$70

Wheat

Eggs

milk

add ons

strawberry filling

fresh strawberry

chocolate drizzle

red velvet cake

moist red velvet cake with a hint of cocoa and layers of rich cream cheese frosting. elegant, delicious, and perfect for special occasions

6-inch

$40

8-inch

$55

10- inch

$70

Wheat

milk

Eggs

add ons

extra cream cheese frosting

red velvet crumbs decorations

butter cream flowers

$10

Featured

Tres leche cake

soft vanilla cake soaked in three sweet milks and topped with fresh whipped cream. rich, creamy, and melt-in-your mouth delicious.

6-inch

$40

8-inch

$55

10- inch

$70

9x13

$45

half sheet cake

$75

Wheat

Eggs

milk

add-ons

fresh strawberry

mixed berries

$10

peaches

cheese cakes

Featured

classic cheesecake

A smooth, creamy classic made with rich cream cheese and a buttery graham cracker crust. Lightly sweet, velvety, and perfectly balanced — this cheesecake is delicious on its own or customized with your favorite toppings. A timeless choice for any occasion.

$30

Wheat

Eggs

dairy

add ons

fresh strawberry

blueberry compote

salted caramal drizzle

Featured

chocolate cheesecake

A rich, velvety chocolate cheesecake made with premium cocoa and smooth cream cheese, baked on a buttery chocolate cookie crust. Deep, indulgent, and perfectly balanced — this one is for true chocolate lovers. Add toppings or custom décor to make it uniquely yours.

$32

dairy

Wheat

Eggs

Soy

add ons

fresh strawberry

blueberry compote

salted caramal drizzle

Featured

peanut butter cheesecake

A rich, ultra‑creamy peanut butter cheesecake made with smooth peanut butter blended into velvety cream cheese, baked on a buttery graham or Oreo crust. It’s sweet, salty, and perfectly indulgent — a dream dessert for peanut butter lovers. Add toppings or custom décor to make it even more irresistible.

$35

dairy

Eggs

Peanuts

Soy

add ons

chocolate ganache

reese's crumble

peanut butter drizzle

Featured

strawberry cheesecake

A smooth, creamy classic cheesecake topped with a generous layer of sweet strawberry topping and fresh sliced strawberries. Made with rich cream cheese and a buttery graham crust, this cheesecake is light, fruity, and beautifully balanced — the perfect blend of fresh and indulgent.

$32

dairy

Wheat

Eggs

Soy

add ons

extra fresh strawberries

strawberry compote

whipped cream swirls

Featured

oreo cheesecake

A rich and creamy cheesecake loaded with crushed Oreo cookies and baked on a chocolatey Oreo crust. Smooth, sweet, and packed with cookies‑and‑cream flavor in every bite. Finished with whipped cream swirls and extra Oreo pieces for the perfect classic treat.

$35

dairy

Wheat

Eggs

Soy

add ons

extra oreo crumble

chocolate ganache

whipped cream swirls

Featured

raspberry-lemon cheesecake

A bright and refreshing cheesecake bursting with fresh lemon flavor and swirled with sweet‑tart raspberry puree. Made on a buttery graham crust, this cheesecake is the perfect balance of creamy, citrusy, and fruity. Finished with a glossy raspberry topping and optional lemon zest for a beautiful, vibrant presentation.

$35

dairy

Wheat

Eggs

Soy

add ons

extra raspberry topping

fresh raspberries

lemon zest sprinkles

small treats

banana bread

A soft, moist, perfectly sweet banana bread made with ripe bananas and warm vanilla. Baked until golden with a tender crumb, this classic loaf is comforting, nostalgic, and perfect for breakfast, snacking, or gifting. Add mix‑ins or toppings to make it uniquely yours.

full loaf

$12

mini loaf

dairy

Wheat

Eggs

Lactose free

Soy

add ons

chocolate chips

walnuts

pecans

pumpkin roll

A soft, spiced pumpkin cake rolled with a silky sweet cream cheese filling. Light, fluffy, and perfectly balanced with warm cinnamon and pumpkin spice. Each slice gives that cozy fall flavor everyone loves — ideal for holidays, gifting, or anytime you want something indulgent and beautiful.

full roll

$20

half roll

$10

dairy

Wheat

Eggs

add ons

extra cream cheese filling

cinnamon sugar dusting

toasted pecans

brownies

Thick, fudgy, melt‑in‑your‑mouth brownies baked with rich cocoa and real butter. Each square has a crackly top, soft center, and deep chocolate flavor that feels indulgent and homemade. Perfect for parties, gifting, or satisfying any chocolate craving.

full pan

$20

half pan

$10

individual squares

dairy

Wheat

Eggs

Soy

add ons

chocolate chips

walnuts

pecans

rice Krispie treats

Soft, chewy, buttery Rice Krispie treats made with gooey marshmallows and just the right amount of sweetness. Each square has that perfect pull‑apart texture and nostalgic flavor everyone loves. Great for parties, kids’ events, dessert tables, or custom orders with fun mix‑ins.

full pan

$18

half pan

individual squares

dairy

Wheat

Soy

add ons

mini M &Ms

chocolate chips

oreo crumble

cinnamon roll

Soft, fluffy cinnamon rolls baked golden and swirled with warm cinnamon‑brown sugar filling. Each roll is rich, buttery, and melts in your mouth. Finished with your choice of creamy vanilla icing or decadent cream cheese frosting. Perfect for breakfast, gifting, or any cozy moment.

half a dozen(6)

$14

a dozen (12)

$28

single roll

dairy

Eggs

Wheat

gluten

add ons

extra cream cheese filling

cream cheese frosting upgrade

maple glaze

chocolate- covered strawberries